When is Art pornography?
Mumbai: A recent news report mentioned that a Chinese woman landed herself in trouble when she tried to sell an ancient mirror containing an image which had four pairs of lovers on it. She was arrested on charges of selling pornography. In Mumbai too, artists have often faced flak for art that has been ‘misconstrued’ as pornography.
One of the most prominent cases being that of renowned artist Akbar Padamsee who was arrested for his ‘nude’ works in 1954. “Both the lower and higher courts upheld my view,” he asserts. “I think pornography is in the mind of the spectator and it is the latter who must be taken to the psychiatrist, not the artist.”
Another instance is the exhibition Futurisitic Shiva by artist Rajat Dhar that showed at Ashish Balram Nagpal’s gallery last year. “It got me into a tangle with the cops because it focused on Shiva’s torso,” says Nagpal. “I also had a serious problem when I presented Sanjeev Khandekar’s show in 2007 called Tits, Clits and Elephant Dick at Jehangir Art Gallery. Someone filed a litigation saying his work was all about nudity,” he recalls. “It’s not right. You can’t censor art; it goes against what it stands for.”
Echoes gallery owner Shireen Gandhy on the public uproar of Khandekar’s exhibition that resulted in the work subsequently being taken out by the management of the gallery. “That was the most reprimandable thing! It makes my blood boil and I feel so disgruntled and sick about it as it had become a whole moral police issue.”
But secretary of Jehangir Art Gallery, K G Menon, has a differing view. “Our management has taken a strong objection to nude works being shown in the gallery; works that are ‘unbearable’ are not put up. That is because this is a public gallery and we have even five and six-year-olds coming in and such nude works can definitely harm their young minds.”
Gallery owner Vickram Sethi has the last say, “In India, we have such a convoluted view of pornography and it’s quite a hypocritical stance. Look at Indian mythology — it borders on the erotic!”